|
Directed by |
|
Starring |
|
Specs |
|
Languages |
- English: Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround
- English: Dolby Digital Mono
|
Subtitles |
|
Extras |
- 10 Deleted scenes
- 11 Theatrical trailer
- 3 Featurette
- 4 Photo gallery
- 1 Documentaries
- Short film - Camille (1926)
|
|
|
A Woman of Paris: SE |
Warner Bros./Warner Home Video .
R4 . B&W . 78 mins .
PG . PAL |
Feature |
|
Contract |
|
Chaplin’s first effort at purely directing (and a noticeable absence of the Little Tramp) sees him writing a story of Marie St. Claire, separated from her lover by her intimidating father before escaping to Paris. Here she spends several years waiting for her former love who never received the letter telling him to meet her there. (Shades of Romeo + Juliet of course… ).
In time she comes to terms with her loss and begins living a lavish lifestyle amidst the playboys of Paris and slipping into a less moralistic life. Then, by chance, she bumps into her former love and well, I shan’t give away anything more here. Told in abject silence, there’s no room for dialogue other than those generally necessary character statements upon which the story may well hang. Apart from those, the dialogue is mostly portrayed in actions and expressions from the individuals concerned. However, with Chaplin’s usual moral lowground playing a major part here, the audience of the time (and indeed, quite possibly today) found not much to hold their interest with Chaplin’s notable humour totally absent. Still, for 1923, this kind of indepth exploration of character was practically unheard of as cinema began to come of age. For those folks who’ve enjoyed the other recent releases of Chaplin’s masterworks, you may find not a lot to hold you here with the aforementioned absence of humour or the lovable Little Tramp. However, for anyone who enjoys Chaplin’s work for the creative genius he is (and was), there are numerous moments here of incredible depth and perception. Worth it for the hardcore fans, but for the casual Chaplin observer there are better and funnier offerings about.
Video |
|
Contract |
|
Well, like the stable of other releases here, the picture quality is as good as it could possibly get for a black and white print of over 80 years in age. Good depth of shadow detail and layered darks make the picture give up everything it is supposed to in this (naturally0 4:3 delivery. No widescreen back then and of course, there are film artefacts (though nothing heartbreaking).
Audio |
|
Contract |
|
Again feeling there is some urge to stretch an original mono track into Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround, this is the case. This is of course done to appeal to the sound junkies who just gotta have surround, but when a film is practically silent I truly can’t see the point. We do have the more recent Chaplin score attached however - this was the score Chaplin wrote at age 86 for the film’s 70s release. Notably, this second ‘new and improved’ score was Chaplin’s final work before he passed away.
Extras |
|
Contract |
|
Overall |
|
Contract |
|
Fans who’ve got this far through The Chaplin Collection may well wanna drop what they’re doing and get a hold of this, but for the casual observer there’s not much here to grab. While the morals are interesting for the day and ahead of their time (it would seem), that’s about the only appeal of this Chaplin directorial effort (apart from his uncredited cameo early in the piece).
LINK: http://www.dvd.net.au/review.cgi?review_id=4330
Send to a friend.
|
|
|
And I quote... |
"...for the casual Chaplin observer there’s not much here to grab..." - Jules Faber |
|
Review Equipment |
- DVD Player:
Teac DVD-990
- TV:
AKAI CT-T29S32S 68cm
- Speakers:
Teac PLS-60 Home Theatre System
- Centre Speaker:
Teac PLS-60 Home Theatre System
- Surrounds:
Teac PLS-60 Home Theatre System
- Subwoofer:
Akai
- Audio Cables:
Standard RCA
- Video Cables:
Standard Component RCA
|
Recent Reviews: |
|
|
Related Links |
|
|